Post Truth: Dishonest Leadership by Another Name

Post Truth: Dishonest Leadership by Another Name

We can call it post truth but it’s just dishonest leadership by a different name.

Bernie Sanders, Vermont senator and former presidential candidate, branded US President-elect Donald Trump “a pathological liar”. The New York Times shone a light on his lies about the popular vote. If that seems too partisan to you, check out Politifact, the independent fact-checking website that rates Trump as making true statements 4% of the time. Compare that to a combined score where his statements are “mostly false”, “false” and “pants on fire” at 70%.

Thing is, Trump’s not the only one who’s a fan of dishonest leadership. National Geographic’s show on climate change, The Years of Living Dangerously, tells us that in Nevada and Florida energy companies are actively campaigning to eliminate solar energy. In Florida the utility-backed Consumers for Smart Solar launched a petition to let state and local regulators decide on the future of solar. The problem? It was a look-a-like petition to Floridians for Solar Choice that would allow independently run solar installations across the state. The result? Confused consumers sign the Consumers for Smart Solar petition thinking they’re advocating full solar choice.

It’s probably good for the short term profits of those energy companies, but the dishonest leadership means trust (already in short supply) is eroded, in companies and in our societies.

A title doesn’t make someone a good leader, it’s a mindset: a way of looking at the world. And the first place we start leading—the first person we lead—is ourselves. We all know if we’re lying. We feel that sharp pang of inauthenticity.

Eight years ago I found myself living a life that wasn’t authentic. When I pulled the emergency brake on that life I realized how dishonest leadership is a short term strategy. It’s when I began to focus on my own leadership mindset.

Our professional lives are no different, but we often don’t take the risk to speak out when we know our business or our leaders are being dishonest. Leadership isn’t just about the people at the very top, it’s about people throughout an entire organization or country, leading in their sphere of influence.

For me that’s the mindset we need as our world lurches toward an uncertain future ripe with dishonest leadership. There will always be demagogues willing to take advantage of those left behind by things like globalization; by those who feel bullied by an establishment that has long since stopped working for them.

Leadership isn’t about exploiting the desperation of others. A leadership mindset is about showing others what they’re capable of becoming.

If people want to follow us that’s not a game it’s a privilege. It’s a time for selflessness; for doing what’s in the best interests of all, not the few.

There’s a question I think a leader needs to ask themselves several times a day. It’s a simple question with what should be a simple answer. It’s this: “Now that people are following you, are you proud of where you’re leading them?”


Want blogs like this in your inbox?

Programmes you may find useful…

Looking for a dramatically different approach to change management? Our Leading Through Change programme explores the impact of change on your people and gives you the awareness, skills and techniques to confidently take on the mantle of leading through change effectively.

Together We Are Stronger is our Senior Leadership Team programme. It hones and develops the unique skill set that allows strong leaders to come together in a shared vision to move an organization forward. That includes the courage to ask tough questions; the wisdom to act decisively when needed, and the ability to build strong working relationships with each other. Designed to meet the needs of your senior leadership team, this is a fluid and bespoke programme.

At Innate Leaders we know that 95% of the time your management team works as effectively as possible. Our Managers to Leaders programme works with managers to give them the courage and ability to lead your business.


Contact Innate Leaders for
more information on any of
our services.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *